Arts Advocacy News - November 2008

   Arts Advocacy News
January 2009
In This Issue
Weathering the Storm: The Recession and the Arts
Are You "Shovel Ready"? Feds Tackle the Recession
Save the Date: Feb. 24, 2009: IAA Members' Meeting and Reception
Save the Date: June 1-2, 2009: One State Conference
Upcoming Events
The Shrinking Media and
What It Means for

Your Arts Organization

January 15 at 6 pm
Columbia College
Film Row Cinema
Panelists include
IAA's Scarlett Swerdlow


Break on Through:
The Creative Response
to
Tough Times

January 27 at 9 am
Chicago Cultural Center
Sponsored by IAA,
Chicago Cultural Center,
and Arts & Business
Council of Chicago


2009 IAA Members'
Meeting and Reception
February 24 at 3 pm
Steppenwolf Theatre

2009 National
Arts Advocacy Day

March 30 and 31
Washington, DC

2009 One State:
Together in the Arts
Conference

June 1 and 2
Peoria, Illinois
Sponsored by IAA and
the Illinois Arts Council

For more information on
the above events,
contact IAA at
info@artsalliance.org or
312-855-3105.
Forward to a Friend
Dear Friend in the Arts,

This new year brings new challenges and unprecedented change for many in the arts. More and more artists and cultural workers are wringing their hands over the deepening recession, a $2 billion state budget shortfall, and rising unemployment rates.

In case you missed it, Illinois Issues devoted its entire December edition to the threats and opportunities affecting our state's creative sector.
 
So how will artists and arts organizations in Illinois confront the challenges that lie ahead? In this issue, we offer tools, information, and events to help our members navigate the economic downturn, see change as opportunity, and capitalize on creativity.
 
As we enter 2009, let us resolve to embrace change and take on the challenges of our time with energy, innovation, and perseverance.
 
Many thanks for all you do,

Ra Joy's Signature
Ra Joy
Executive Director
joy@artsalliance.org

WEATHERING THE STORM: THE RECESSION & THE ARTS
IAA Forum on Response to the Economy: Jan. 27, 2009
In December, unemployment rates continued to climb, home values continued to plummet, and consumer confidence reached an all-time low. Increasingly, nonprofits are joining all Americans in bracing for leaner and much tougher times.

In October, when we first considered the economic crisis, when it came to the total impact the downturn may have on the cultural community, there were few sure or absolute answers. Today, while the road is still wrought with uncertainty, the challenges and opportunities that await us are more apparent.

Weathering the Storm

Undeniably, the downturn is affecting the arts. As artists and arts organizations weather this storm, they may encounter steep reductions in state support and fewer foundation and corporate dollars as well as shrinking audiences and diminishing patronage.

The economy here in Illinois is officially in recession, according to a report released by the University of Illinois on January 6, 2009. And as J. Fred Giertz of the U of I Institute of Government and Public Affairs told the State Journal-Register, "The question is how low will it fall?"

"We're going into recession with no reserves, a huge backlog of unpaid bills, and a budget that was unbalanced even before the recession came," Giertz went on to tell Illinois Issues.

In its January edition, Illinois Issues details the economic challenges and obstacles we will face in 2009. Some of Illinois' problems are common throughout the US: 31 states expect shortfalls in state revenue through the end of fiscal year 2009, and declines in jobs and spending are a national trend. Unique to Illinois, though, are the $4 billion backlog in bills the State of Illinois has and the $4 billion payout in pensions the State must muster up for state workers in 2009. Add to that the $0 balance on our "rainy day" fund, and Illinois is facing a severe fiscal crisis.

A recent report from Donors Forum offers an overview of the effect of the economic downturn on Illinois' nonprofits as well as the community's proactive and creative responses to current challenges.

The Donors Forum, which works to strengthen Illinois philanthropy and nonprofits, convened a dialogue with donors in December titled "In Times Like These: Coping in a Slack Economy" to assess the impact of the downturn on philanthropy in Illinois as well as offer advice and strategies to nonprofits. The forum featured IAA Board Member Donald Cooke of the McCormick Foundation as well as representatives from Northern Trust, Polk Brothers Foundation, and Metropolitan Family Services. A transcript is available online.

Money

Tough Times for Nonprofits

A takeaway from the Donors Forum event is that fundraising and development will be fraught with significant challenges for the cultural community in 2009.


While foundations are feeling the recession, they may be one of the more stable funding channels available to nonprofits in 2009. According to the Foundation Center, a few factors may moderate the impact of the downturn on overall foundation giving. For example, many foundations average the value of their assets over two to five years when determining how much they will give in a year. This means that losses in 2008 may be offset by gains in previous years.

Plus, the Foundation Center reports that the priorities of foundations do not shift suddenly in the face of reduced resources. Specifically, the research shows that giving to the arts and culture has remained steady during past downturns in the economy.

The outlook for corporations is less optimistic. An article in the Wall Street Journal warns that corporations are scaling back in giving: "The pipeline from corporate America to the nation's charities is starting to dry up, as losses in the stock market mount and the recession deepens."

Wall Street

More difficult to forecast than foundation or corporate support is individual giving. On the one hand, a recent report from the Center on Philanthropy suggests that giving is recession-proof: individual donations to nonprofits have increased every year except one since 1968. Plus, a handful of the top philanthropists in America intend to give more in 2009 than in previous years, according to a Business Week article.

On the other hand, a GuideStar survey found that the number of nonprofits reporting a decrease in contributions doubled between 2007 and 2008.

Moreover, in December, nonprofits reported the lowest level of confidence in the fundraising climate in more than ten years, according to a Philanthropic Giving Index report by the Center on Philanthropy. (The Philanthropic Giving Index is similar to a Consumer Confidence Index for giving to nonprofits.)

With contradictory reports and information, what are arts and cultural organizations to think? As a New York Times article states, "So far, few fundraising experts or nonprofit leaders are predicting an implosion in giving, a long fall from the more than $300 billion that was donated in 2007 in the United States. But nonetheless they acknowledge that their world has changed and are preparing for leaner times. It's more a matter of when, not if."

Break on Through: The Creative Response to Tough Times

While there is no doubt that the downturn in the economy is a severe challenge to the arts and cultural community in Illinois, it's not in our nature to submit to despair or passivity. On the other side of the current uncertainty is the opportunity to capitalize on creativity and promote the strength and impact of our state's cultural sector.

To explore this opening, in partnership with the Chicago Department of Cultural Affairs and the Arts & Business Council of Chicago, IAA will co-host "Break on Through: The Creative Response to Tough Times" on January 27, 2009 at 9 am at the Chicago Cultural Center on 77 East Randolph Street in the Claudia Cassidy Theater. Click here to register online.

Paul O'ConnorFirst, Paul O'Connor (pictured to the right), a nonprofit consultant and the founding executive director of World Business Chicago, will comment on the importance of an active and vibrant arts community to the vitality of Illinois.

Then, a panel of dynamic, r
espected, and entrepreneurial arts leaders will lead a wide-ranging discussion of the individual and collective steps cultural organizations can take to position the sector not only for near-term endurance, but for a thriving, post-recession expansion.

"I personally think that America's economic future depends upon a robust cultural exchange between the incompatible perspectives of business and the arts," O'Connor told IAA. "The MBAs of Mars must hybridize with the MFAs of Venus; connect-the-dot business logic must learn how to make intuitive, creative leaps forward. In short, the arts have something to sell that business desperately needs: creative thinking. I see this as an urgent national priority."

"The businesses that - in desperation perhaps - taste the creative Kool-Aid will never be without it again," O'Connor continued. "[They] will take their financial relationships with arts organizations into new forms of two-way commerce."

Admission to "The Creative Response to Tough Times" is free, but space is limited. Register online today, or contact Scarlett Swerdlow at IAA at swerdlow@artsalliance.org or 312-855-3105 x13 if you have any questions.

(Pictured below: the Tiffany Dome at the Cultural Center.)


Tiffany Dome at the Cultural Center

Tools to Help You Weather the Storm

The Foundation Center - with its online hub of information on the economy - continues to be an outstanding resource for arts professionals concerned about the economic crisis.

In addition to hosting "The Creative Response to Tough Times" forum, IAA is using delicious, an online bookmarking tool, to maintain a thorough, running list of ready-resources available online for artists and arts organizations to access. Visit http://delicious.com/tag/artsrecession to check out articles, commentary, research, and tools about the downturn in the economy. If you are a delicious user, use the tag "artsrecession" to share relevant resources.

As more information and resources become available, we will continue to share them with you. In the meantime, we want to hear your stories about the impact of the economy on your work. Are you:
  • Facing a severe cut in municipal funding?
  • Being forced to cut programs or lay off staff as a result of the economic downturn?
  • In jeopardy of losing critical foundation or corporate support?
Please share you stories by contacting Scarlett Swerdlow at IAA at swerdlow@artsalliance.org or 312-855-3105 x13.

ARE YOU "SHOVEL READY"? FEDS TACKLE THE RECESSION

Not only are individual artists and arts organizations trying to weather the economic storm, lawmakers are also struggling to address the threats and opportunities that the recession poses.

In December, the National Conference of State Legislatures issued an analysis of the topics that will top the agendas of state governments in 2009. According to the report, shortfalls in state budgets will dominate the sessions of many state legislatures: "Money will be the No. 1 issue for states in 2009." Money will top the agenda in Springfield too as Illinois wrestles with a $2 billion budget deficit as well as a $4 billion backlog in bills and a 3-month delay in payments.

Mo' Money

Obama's American Recovery and Reinvestment Plan

The economy will also dominate President-elect Barack Obama's first 100 days in the White House. President-elect Obama has identified the passage of an economic stimulus package as his top priority.

"Economists from across the political spectrum agree that if we don't act swiftly and boldly," President-elect Obama told Americans in his weekly address on January 3, 2009, "we could see a much deeper economic downturn that could lead to double digit unemployment and the American dream slipping further and further out of reach."

Obama's solution to the recession: the American Recovery and Reinvestment Plan, a stimulus package that "not only creates jobs in the short-term, but spurs economic growth and competitiveness in the long-term." According to President-elect Obama, "We must make strategic investments that will serve as a down payment on our long-term economic future."

(Click on the image below to watch President-elect Obama's January 3, 2009 address.)

President-elect Obama

The objective of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Plan is to preserve and create 3 million or more jobs through the next two years, and the Plan includes three tactics: investment in American infrastructure, such as roads, bridges, and schools; assistance to the middle class; and support for states struggling with revenue shortfalls.

Federal investment in infrastructure is a critical component of Obama's plan. Specifically, local and regional projects that are "shovel-ready" and can start within 60 days will be prioritized for federal funding.

Supporting "Shovel-Ready" Arts Projects

This presents a window of opportunity for the arts and cultural community to contribute to and benefit from the stimulus package. Several arts and culture initiatives are included in the "ready to go" report released by the US Conference of Mayors on December 19, 2008, and the Mayors' 10-Point Plan for a Strong America states that "the arts are critical to the quality of life and livability of America's cities." In addition to calling for full funding of the arts and culture, the nation's mayors also "urge the creation of a Cabinet level Secretary of Culture and Tourism charged with forming a national policy for arts, culture and tourism."

There are several ways that the federal government could channel money to arts and culture infrastructure projects including:
(To access the Americans for the Arts guide on one of the above programs, click on the hyperlinked description of that program.)

To position the arts as central to our economic recovery, it is essential that we share examples of successful local and state arts projects that were federally funded through these programs.

Are you aware of an arts or culture project in your community that was federally funded through the CDGB, Rural Development, or Transportation Enhancement programs? Do you know of a federally funded initiative in which artists, arts organizations, or designers played a substantial role? If so, please contact Scarlett Swerdlow at IAA at swerdlow@artsalliance.org or 312-855-3105 x13.

An Arts Stimulus Plan

In addition to positioning the arts within the existing recovery plan, others are calling for a direct stimulus package to bolster America's cultural sector.

Michael Kaiser, president of the John F Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, authored an op-ed calling for emergency funding for artists and arts organizations which ran in hundreds of papers on December 29, 2008. "No bailout for the Arts?" argues the arts are critical to our country's health now more than ever:

"We are losing the entertainment and inspiration we need more than ever during this terribly scary time. As we try to rebuild America's image abroad, we are losing our most potent goodwill ambassadors. As we reshape our economy, we are losing the organizations that teach our children to think creatively. And as we celebrate the diversity of our nation, we are losing the voices that have traditionally helped change society's thinking."

Some artists and activists have also been circulating an online petition calling upon Congress to appropriate 1 percent of the stimulus package toward arts and culture. Building on the tradition of the New Deal's Federal Art Project and Federal Writers Project, advocates are suggesting an arts stimulus plan could be used to hire cultural workers, strengthen arts in public spaces, support artist- and writer-in-residence programs, and more.

In the coming weeks, leaders in Washington, DC and Springfield will be working to craft a new vision for our country and the state. We look forward to working together to position the arts as essential to reviving the economy, creating local jobs, and sharpening our state's competitive edge and international reputation. Please be on the lookout for news and action alerts later this month asking you to take action to support the arts in Illinois.

Congress
SAVE THE DATE: FEB. 24, 2009: IAA MEMBERS' MEETING
Ben Cameron to Discuss Change and Renewal in the Arts

The Illinois Arts Alliance will host its annual Members' Meeting and Reception on Tuesday, February 24, 2009 at 3 pm at Steppenwolf Theatre in Chicago.

The Members' Meeting is an opportunity to network with other arts professionals and supporters and discuss issues of importance to the arts community in Illinois.

Ben CameronBen Cameron (pictured to the right), a nationally renowned speaker, former theater professional, and arts activist, will touch on the concepts of change, transition, and renewal and their meaning for the arts in an engaging keynote address.

Currently, Cameron manages a $17 million grant program for the arts at the Doris Duke Charitable Foundation, but he also has experience as an artist and arts administrator. Prior to joining the Foundation in 2006, he served as executive director of Theatre Communications Group from 1998 to 2006 and director of the theater program of the National Endowment for the Arts from 1990 to 1992.  

Close to 200 arts professionals and supporters attended the 2008 Members' Meeting and Reception which featured a talk by Carol Coletta of CEOs for Cities titled "The Creative City" as well as a moderated discussion with David Hawkanson of Steppenwolf Theatre, Tony Jones of the School of the Art Institute, and Mayor Lorraine Morton of Evanston. Video of Carol's remarks and photos of the event are available online.

Look out for a formal announcement of the 2009 Members' Meeting and Reception in your inbox soon. In the meantime, you can contact Sharon Tulos at IAA at tulos@artsalliance.org or 312-855-3105 x12 if you have a question or request regarding the event.

(Pictured below: Carol Coletta and David Hawkanson at the 2008 Members' Meeting and Reception.)

2008 Members' Meeting and Reception
SAVE THE DATE: JUNE 1-2, 2009: ONE STATE
See Change Is Theme of Statewide Conference in Peoria

On June 1 and 2, 2009 in Peoria, Illinois at the Hotel Pere Marquette, arts administrators and practitioners of all disciplines and from all regions of the state will come together to learn, share, and celebrate the arts at the 2009 One State: Together in the Arts conference.

Now in its sixth year, the biennial One State conference is co-convened by IAA and the Illinois Arts Council. One State is the only statewide, multidisciplinary conference for artists and arts organizations in Illinois.

(Picture below: presenters from the 2007 One State in Champaign.)

2007 One State

All conference sessions will touch on the theme of See Change, whether from the perspective of:
  • Creating and sustaining effective internal organizational change;
  • Tuning into and working with the environmental changes in which we seek to thrive; or
  • Gauging and strengthening the local, national, and international impact of our work.
To truly represent the issues and experts of Illinois, the Arts Alliance and the Arts Council have released a request for proposals for conference sessions. The deadline for submissions is January 16, 2009.

For breaking conference news and announcements, sign up for IAA's special One State eList. In the meantime, if you have a question or request about One State, contact Lisa May Simpson at IAA at simpson@artsalliance.org or 312-855-3105 x15.

More information on the 2009 One State as well as the 2007, 2005, and 2003 conferences is also available online.

(Picture below: Networking at the 2007 One State.)

2007 One State
The Illinois Arts Alliance (IAA) is the statewide arts advocacy and service organization promoting the value of the arts to all residents of Illinois.


Illinois Arts Alliance
203 North Wabash Avenue
Suite 1920
Chicago, Illinois 60601
312.855.3105
www.artsalliance.org
All Arts Advocacy News content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share-Alike 3.0 United States License unless otherwise noted.

Image Credits:

Ominous clouds hanging over the hills - Flickr user 42dreams
Twenties - Flickr user crazyneighborlady
Wall Street subway mosaic - Flickr user epicharmus
Untitled (Paul O'Connor) - Mireya Acierto / Chicago Reader
top of the dome - Flickr user cgin03
081214 cash money - Flickr user dan4th
DSC_0084 - Flickr user robnaldo
Untitled (Ben Cameron) - Ben Cameron
1056 Carol Coletta and David Hawkanson - Flickr user illinoisartsalliance
Ling-Ti Huang, Caroline Worra, et al - Flickr user illinoisartsalliance
Animated conversations - Flickr user illinoisartsalliance